I Have No Game, and I Must Blog


S. Ben Melhuish • Saturday, November 28, 2009 • filed under settings, shelves

Important update — March 22, 2022

The original post (below) was written in 2009. This morning, RPG historian Shannon Appelcline reported on news that has been circulating for the past week or so: M.A.R. Barker, the creator of the Tékumel setting that I write about in this article, was secretly a neo-Nazi.

I’m not lacking for ways to spend my money — books to buy, movies to watch, games to play — and I’m not going to intentionally give money to problematic people (or other entities). Barker died years ago, so any future purchases I make obviously won’t support him. However, as Appelcline points out in his article, the Tékumel Foundation, which curates Barker’s published and unpublished works, also licenses the setting to other publishers, and it seems they’ve been sitting on this news for ten years, if not longer. I presume they draw a licensing fee from any licensed Tékumel publication, and I can’t send any money their way, either.

I’m not necessarily going to get rid of the Tékumel publications I already have. As I read them, I didn’t notice anything more troublesome than (for example) the run-of-the-mill fondness for imperialism that’s so common in gaming and sci-fi/fantasy culture. As Appelcline also points out, though, what Nazi subtexts might be buried — intentionally or subconsciously — in its foundation or superstructure? If I were to run, or play in, a Tékumel game, how much work would it be to scrutinize each bit of the setting for Nazi elements? Obviously we should always be interrogating our reading and viewing, but a work with known neo-Nazi connections requires a much higher level of scrutiny. I can’t imagine it’s worth it.

At this point, the best use I can think for Barker’s work is to mine it for ideas. I love the idea, for example, of millennia-old cities that are razed every few hundred years and rebuilt using the old city as a foundation. Even better would be to put that in service of an explicitly-inclusive and -non-Nazi agenda. It sure would be satisfying to make Barker turn over in his grave.

I’ve left the following post untouched, except for one tiny thing: I originally referred to Barker as “Prof. Barker”. It’s the standard way to refer to him in the gaming industry, and I shrugged and continued the affectation here. It feels especially distasteful with the revelations that he was a neo-Nazi, though, and I’ve removed the honorific. I’ve otherwise made no changes to the text, preserving it for posterity.

Original post

At least by some accounts, the second RPG ever published was Empire of the Petal Throne, heavily based on the original D&D rules1 but set in the exotic world of Tékumel. Created by M.A.R. Barker, Tékumel is a pulp fantasy setting inspired in part by Mesoamerican and Indian cultures. In the far future, that world had been terraformed to Earth standards, its original inhabitants pent up in reservations, and turned into a resort destination. And then at some point, the world got shunted to a pocket dimension, cutting it off from the rest of the galaxy; its inhabitants fell into barbarism, though discovering how to draw and harness power through the thin barriers between their new dimension and other nearby ones (what we would call magic).

The default focus of the setting is the Tsolyáni Empire, built on the ruins of two or three fallen empires; it’s a conservative culture, where magic use is strictly controlled, metal is rare and precious, and the status of your clan determines your path in life (except for exceptional individuals, such as the player characters!).2

Mixed feelings

Tékumel has a great premise—you’ve got your long-lost fallen empires, technology that is considered to be (and may as well be, or may even also be) magic, an excuse for any horrific monster you may want; what more do you need for a game?

But the baroqueness of the setting, an obvious part of its appeal, also sets up a huge barrier to entry. It may well be (as some say) that the setting becomes second nature after a few sessions, but it looks like the learning curve will be steep.

What to do

With all the differences from your “standard” fantasy setting, perhaps the most important problem I see is player buy-in. It looks like you’d need a group which is 100% gung-ho to play a game in Tékumel; otherwise, those who are (presumably including the GM) will pull the weight for those who aren’t so into it. So unless I somehow discovered that my regular gaming group has been dying to do this, I can’t see ever using Tékumel as-is.

Which isn’t to say I’d never use it. As long as nobody in a group is violently opposed to science in their fantasy (and that deserves a small post of its own!), it could be very fun to drop bits and pieces of the setting into whatever game was being played—tubeway stations deep beneath ancient cities, whose cars could take the characters anywhere; ancient magic items powered by even more-ancient technology; domed cities in the far north, filled with chlorine gas and hostile alien races.

An alternative might be a completely unserious approach: Max out the pulp dial, dismiss anything that doesn’t lead to more action, and go! Pulp’s picaresque storytelling minimizes any need for player commitment, and the GM can blithely ignore the accumulated cruft of decades of Tékumel play without worry.4

(Both alternatives remind me of another post subject, collective setting creation. So we have HeroQuest, science fantasy, and setting creation added to the backlog.)

Tékumel: a fun place to visit, but I wouldn’t want to live there. I’d love to set a game there sometime, but only if it’s handled just right.

(If you’re intrigued by my hasty sketch of the setting, you could do worse than visit tekumel.com and browse through the Eye of Illuminating Glory section.)

  1. A brief digression on rules: As noted, the first published rules for Tékumel, Empire of the Petal Throne, were a modified version of D&D, published by TSR. These were followed, at roughly ten-year intervals, by Swords and Glory, Gardásiyal, and Tékumel: Empire of the Petal Throne, the last of which I own. I have no particular affection for the rules themselves, and would almost certainly use something like HeroQuest (which deserves a post of its own). ↩︎

  2. This may sound familiar to readers of the first generation of post-D&D fantasy novels. ↩︎

  3. If you must search for chlén on the internet, please use a proper query, or else don’t search at work. ↩︎

  4. Naturally the GM should never worry about a setting’s “canon”, but this often doesn’t happen in practice. ↩︎